International Comparisons of Energy Efficiency

  Why do some countries use energy more efficiently than others? How is it possible that when the United States was less dependent on imported energy in 1973 it was affected significantly by a world energy crisis, and that it is more dependent on energy imports today with no apparent signs of an impending energy crisis? Answers to these quesions depend on the underlying price and income elasticities of supply and demand, as well on the role of technology. While today's energy environment may seem relatively calm, the potential for a new energy crisis will depend on what kinds of policies are adopted by the United States and the major energy consuming countries in the world.

The first point of comparison is the relationship between energy intensity and per capita income. Energy intensity measures the standardized energy consumption from all forms of energy needed to produce a dollar's worth of output, using a standard measure of output such as GDP, GNP, or National Income.

PPP GNP per Capita, $U.S. 1995

KG of Oil Equivalent per $U.S. 1987 Dollar Equivalent GDP
India 1400 0.625
Philippines 2850 0.526
China 2920 1.4285
Indonesia 3800 0.5555
Russia 4480 2.0000
South Africa 5030 1.0000
Poland 5400 1.4285
Brazil 5400 0.3571
Turkey 5580 0.5555
Mexico 6400 0.8333
Hungary 6410 1.0000
Thailand 7540 0.4545
Venezuela 7900 0.8333
Argentina 8310 0.3703
Malaysia 9020 0.5882
Chile 9520 0.4347
Czech Republic 9770 1.2500
South Korea 11450 0.5555
Greece 11710 0.4545
Portugal 12670 0.3571
Israel 16490 0.2702
Australia 18940 0.3846
Britain 19260 0.2857
Italy 19870 0.1818
Germany 20070 0.2000
France 21030 0.2272
Canada 21130 0.5000
Japan 22110 0.1612
Singapore 22770 0.6250
Hong Kong 22950 0.1886
United States 26980 0.3846

Source: The World Bank: World Development Indicators 1997 (Washington, D.C.: The World Bank, 1997)

Energy Intensity Premium Gasoline Price $U.S.
Russia 20.00 0.46
Venezuela 8.33 0.9
Turkey 5.55 0.92
China 14.28 0.93
Indonesia 5.55 0.94
Philippines 5.26 1.38
Mexico 8.33 1.41
United States 3.84 1.42
Thailand 4.54 1.44
Canada 5.00 1.92
Chile 4.34 2.16
Malaysia 5.88 2.2
Australia 3.84 2.2
India 6.25 2.25
Poland 14.28 2.29
Brazil 3.57 2.3
South Africa 10.00 2.57
Czech Republic 12.51 2.85
Greece 4.54 3.06
Argentina 3.703 3.1
Israel 2.70 3.2
Singapore 6.25 3.23
Hungary 10.00 3.26
Japan 1.61 3.28
South Korea 5.55 3.82
Portugal 3.57 3.85
Germany 2.00 3.87
Italy 1.81 4.21
France 2.27 4.22
Britain 2.86 4.25
Hong Kong 1.89 4.9

Selected References

Dasgupta, Partha and Geoffrey Heal. Economic Theory and Exhaustible Resources. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979).

Hotelling, Harold. "The Economics of Exhaustibe Resources," The Journal of Political Economy 39:2 (1931), pp. 137-75.

Krautkraemer, Jeffrey, "Nonrenewable Resource Scarcity," Journal of Economic Literature XXXVI:4 (December 1998), pp. 2065-2107.

LeBel, Phillip G. Energy Economics and Technology (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1982).

OECD. World Energy Outlook 1998. (Washington, D.C.: OECD, 1998).

Smith, V. Kerry, editor. Scarcity and Growth Reconsidered. (Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979).

U.S. Department of Energy. Monthly Energy Review. (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office)

Last Updated: 2/7/99

Phillip LeBel

e-mail: LeBelp@mail.edu