ENLT 336 / Nielsen


Student Introduction   

Interview in groups of 3 to 4, and be prepared to introduce someone else you talked to about their:


Course Introduction:
European Romantic Movement



Course Goals:






What words, scenes, legends, people, and history do you associate with the American Revolution? What, if anything, does it mean to you?

- Sam Adams

- only war fought (besides 1812 + Civil War) on soil

- independence, rebellion, Tea Party

- unconventional warfare / Battle of Trenton

- Crispus Attucks

- excluded many people: blacks, women, poor, disabled, homosexuals, children


Keyword Analysis: What did the word romantic mean to the Romantics?


Step 1: In-class writing (individual): Select a keyword from one of the Declarations. Analyze the meaning of the word in its context; its multiple meanings in terms of symbolism, connotation, and syntax; and its importance for understanding a theme in one of the texts. 


Step 2: Read your group's submissions and determine which keyword is most important and/or interesting.


Review of Steps in Keyword Analysis:

- Circle important keywords. Why is it an important word? What's the etymology of the word? What did it mean to the Romantics? What significant role does it play in the syntax of the sentence?

- What symbolic meanings does the word imply?


--> Use for your Close Analyses and other writing (Comparative Paper) in class


- What NOT TO DO: Plot Summary





What do you associate with the words "nature" and "society"?

Nature
Society
how things are

plants, animals

hiking

purity

danger

simplicity

survival

balance

instinct

freedom, lack of restriction
how things should be

structure, social class

laws

rational thought

oppression

corruption

achieve status

progress / industrialism

buildings



Jess: Can Rousseau's attitudes towards gender roles be seen as progressive? Or should they be considered (un)intentionally sexist?

Herb: Did Rousseau believe that the civilization he prescribes can be achieved in reality, or did he offer it merely as a utopian model for what all civilizations should be more like?

Garrett: On page 17 Rousseau states that "Religion commands us to believe that since God himself drew men out of the state of nature, they are unequal because he wanted them to be so" This statement greatly intrigued me because, going back to our discussion on the Deceleration of Independence, our nation was founded on "all men were created equal under God." Why do you think Rousseau felt that way about God and religion and who is more right, men like Thomas Jefferson, or someone like Rousseau and why?

Arianny: I am very much bothered by Rousseau's statement that "Once peoples are accustomed to masters, they are no longer in a position to get along without them. If they try to shake off the yoke, they put all the distance between themselves and liberty, because, in mistaking for liberty an unbridled license which is its opposite, their revolutions nearly always deliver them over to seducers who make the chains heavier" (3). I think his definition of liberty is flat out wrong and is tantamount to saying that the oppressed should just stay in their place instead demanding complete freedom because they're just making things worse for themselves. That makes absolutely no sense to me and actually makes me very angry.

Bianca: I think what confuses me about what Rousseau writes is, he mentions that a child without a mother would die quickly. But how would they die, if someone else can take care of them and feed them the nutrition they need? But Rousseau says that once the direct nutrition is cut off, the baby would die (21).

Michelle P: I am a little confused or maybe I disagree with Rousseau with the statement that when talking about nature "we must deny that, even before the deluge, such a state ever existed among men". I feel that Rousseau is questioning what is and wants proof of what is without accepting what God has provided.

Alex: was confused on the theory that was brought up on page 25, "Some philosophers have even suggested that there is a greater difference between two given men than between a given man and an animal" (Rousseau).







Rousseau's Discourse on the Origin of Inequality addresses the question: "What is the origin of inequality among men, and is it authorized by the natural law?" (Rousseau 16).

What's Rousseau's answer to this question? Find a passage that supports your summary of Rousseau's point (A) and respond in the right-hand column about why you think this inequality exists. Pick 3 out of the 4 categories to address.


Rousseau
You
1. Political Inequalities
p. 51 property; p. 65: family power + "tranquility"
wealth / white supremacy / nature of government, power / no way for fair representation
2. Racial Inequalities
p. 26-7: ignorance; p. 51: savages always savage
white supremacy / colonization
3. Gender Inequalities
p. 48: society
society
4. Economic Inequalities
p. 47: knowledge; p. 53: resources / strength
white supremacy / capitalism / opportunity / birth / class

How did feelings / sensibilities evolve?

34: suicide

38: sympathy / pity

39: love didn't exist for savage man


70: savage "lives in himself"





What causes Werther to commit suicide? Point to at least one textual reference to support your opinion.


- 71: 2 examples of men driven mad by unrequited love for a woman > "condemned man"

- 7: obsessed with finding happiness


- 76: "absorbed in fantastic emotions"

- Romanticism as sickness


- 67: "cup became too bitter"

80: "melancholy attachment"
 
- (81): one of the three needs to die -- "
I am sacrificing myself for you . . . One of us three must go . . .

93:  he thinks Lotte sanctions his death


How does Werther feel about class distinctions?


48: "necessary . . . to have class differences"




Trivia Quiz

1. Where was Rousseau born?

2. A famous novel from the Storm and Stress movement

3. What might a ribbon symbolize in the eighteenth century?

4. Beginning of the French Revolution, as marked by the storming of the Bastille.

Bonus Question: What other date do the French celebrate to mark the Revolution?







Discussion Questions (choose 2 of the 3):

1. What Romantic qualities does Hugo's poem, "Tomorrow, at the point of dawn" (93), evince?

2. Identify the naive and ironic readings of Musset's poem, "On a Dead Woman" (103). What is the significance of this irony?

2. Compare and contrast Goethe's "Fisherman" (13) to Heine's "I don't know what it may signify" (141). Speculate on the significance of these similarities and differences.



Party game: Ask yes or no questions about your character, such as: Do I survive the story? Am I male? etc. Sit down when you finish and write a 1-3 sentence sketch of your character.

Jeronimo Rugera
Donna Josephe Asteron
"little Philip" [Rugera Asteron] (316)
Don Henrico Asteron

Don Fernando Ormez (321)
Donna Elvire Ormez (317)
"little Juan" Ormez (323)
Don Pedro Xares (317)
Donna Elisabeth Xares (317)
Donna Constanze Xares (322)

the Abbess (315)
the Viceroy (318)
Master Pedrillo (321, 323)
Don Alonzo Onoreja (322)


What order do these occur in Faust? Order them, and then respond to one of the quotes: What themes and issues in the tragedy does this quote exemplify?

1. "Should ever I take ease upon a bed of leisure,
May that same moment mark my end!
When first by flattery you lull me
Into a smug complacency,
When with indulgence you can gull me,
Let that day be the last for me!"


2. "Two souls, alas, are dwelling in my breast,
And either would be severed from its brother;
The one holds fast with joyous earthy lust
Onto the world of man with organs clinging;
The other soars impassioned from the dust,
To realms of lofty forebears swinging."

3. "I have pursued, alas, philosophy, / Jurisprudence, and medicine, / And help me God, theology, / With fervent zeal through thick and thin. / And here, poor fool, I stand once more, / No wiser than I was before. / They call me Magister, Doctor, no less, / And for some ten years, I would guess, / Through ups and downs and tos and fros / I have led my pupils by the nose-- / And see there is nothing we can know!"


RIP Gretchen: How would you feel about a real girl who was willing to give her mother a dangerous drug so that she could have sex with her lover in the same bedroom (l. 3510/98)? What is there about the portrait of Gretchen that tends to make us more forgiving of her than of her real-life equivalent?










Rehearse your part(s) for the 2nd, 5th, or 6th scene of Faust II, Act I. If you have multiple parts, try to use a different voice for each part (something you should try to imbue your part with in any case). You can share parts if more people need roles.

2. Imperial Residence (4730-5060/139-46): (144-45/4890-5005: Meph., Chancellor, Emperor, Treasurer + Quartermaster, Marshal, Astrologer, Muttering all [6-7])

5. Dark Gallery (6175/176) (176-79/6180-6305: Faust, Mephistopheles [2])

6. Hall of Chivalry (6455/184) (184-86/6453-6565: Lady + Another, 2nd Lady + Others + Diplomat, 3rd Lady + Knight + Poet, 4th Lady + Young Lady + Savant, Fifth Lady + Older Lady + Astrologer, Sixth Lady + Oldest Lady + Faust, Knight + Courtier + Meph., Chamberlain + the Former [8-22])




Write for 5-10 minutes on 1 of these 2 topics:

1) Does Faust seem like other Romantic texts you have read? Why or why not?



2) What does Faust seem to say about the world of science to you?



Old Men of the Sea:

Nereus > father of Galatea and the Dorids

Act III = Helena Act





Write for 5-10 min.: What is the tragedy of Faust in your opinion?


>> Failure to love anyone truly


Is Faust himself evil?




Write for 5-10 min.: What does monstrosity mean to you?



















Discussion Question: What seems romantic about Frankenstein? In what ways is the writing style similar to Goethe, Rousseau, or other Romantic writers? Try to find examples :)







Pretend that you are explaining what it means "to act like Faust." What does it mean to be Faustian?


The (Romantic) Sublime

Lessons from the De Laceys






Write for 5 min.: To what extent do you think parents are responsible for their children's violence after they abandon them?

Is Frankenstein or society responsible for the monster's violence?











At one point in chapter 4 of vol. 3, Victor Frankenstein expresses remorse over the death his creation causes (132). Yet, he defends Walton's actions to his men by citing the need "to be hailed as the benefactors of your species" in the final chapter (155). In your opinion, has Victor Frankenstein learned the true lesson of striving and ambition, or does he resemble Faust?
















Frankenstein Trivia

1. Frankenstein (1818) was republished in what year?

2. Who is the sole survivor of the Frankenstein family?

3. The creature finds Paradise Lost, Sorrows (Sufferings of Young)
Werther, and what book in the forest?




Is the creature in Frankenstein human? Is Olympia in The Sandman? What constitutes being human then?